PRIMUS
Overview
In 1984 Les Claypool, not long out of high school (Kirk Hammett was a classmate) was running around San Francisco, terrorizing music store owners by testing all of their basses by playing Yes’ Roundabout, listening to Rush, 80s era King Crimson, XTC and 70s funk, writing original material (amongst the earliest were Too Many Puppies, some of the Sausage stuff and a few of the Holy Mackerel album tunes) and looking for a guitar player with an equally unorthodox outlook. After hooking up with high school buddy Todd Huth, the band (at first Primate, later changed to Primus) went through a revolving lineup of drummers. In fact, one of the early drummers was Brain, who broke his foot skate boarding and didn't last long. The first stable lineup was with drummer Tim "Curveball" Wright, who lasted from '86 until early '88. At the time, the band drew heavily on 80s Bay Area influences like the Chili Peppers and Fishbone. Jay Lane took over the drum throne in 1988; the following year both Huth and Lane left (the former to raise a family, the latter due to contractual obligations) and the lineup cemented into Les, Ler Lalonde (with whom Les had played in Blind Illusion) and Tim ‘Herb’ Alexander.
This lineup lasted from 1989 through May of 1996, when Alexander left due to creative differences. In that time they released a number of critically and commercially acclaimed albums (Suck On This, Frizzle Fry, Sailing the Seas of Cheese, Miscellaneous Debris, Pork Soda and Tales From the Punchbowl) and the Cheesy Home video. Primus also toured extensively, cementing their reputation as a potent live band and influencing a generation of future bands, many of whom opened for Primus at one point or another (Limp Bizkit, POD, Incubus, etc.). They played a number of high profile gigs, including opening for both Rush and U2, co-headlining Lollapalooza ’93 and performing at Woodstock ‘94. When touring by themselves, they broke ground by beginning an annual NYE tradition (FreakOuts) in 1992, and by having less commercial bands that they admired open for them (Melvins, Residents, Meat Puppets).
After Tim’s departure, Les and Ler recruited Brian “Brain” Mantia (they also auditioned Jay Lane and Mike ‘Puffy’ Bordin of Faith No More at the time), who cut his teeth first on the Holy Mackerel tour. This lineup released the Brown, Rhinoplasty, and Antipop albums and the Videoplasty and Horrible Swill videos, played a number of multi band tours (HORDE ’97, Sno Core’98, Ozzfest and Family Values ’99) as well as touring on their own and continuing the FreakOut tradition. This version of Primus also introduced unique and offbeat musicians such as DJ Disk and Buckethead to a wider audience, and collaborated with Tom Waits in the studio (he guested on Antipop, Primus played on Waits’ Mule Variations). After a cycle of decreasing support from Interscope and shorter, more formulaic tours in support of Antipop, the band disbanded in April 2000.
Claypool went on to form the Frog Brigade, then Oysterhead and C2B3. When Alexander joined the Frog Brigade for their summer 2002 tour, the atmosphere was set for a Primus reunion. In the fall of 2003, the trio of Les, Ler and Tim released the Animals Should Not Try To Act Like People EP/DVD and engaged upon the groundbreaking Tour de Fromage, with Primus playing two set shows for the first time in their long career, the second set being a complete rendition of the Sailing the Seas of Cheese album. Claypool’s intervening three years of live experimentation and participation in the jam band scene spilled over into Primus, with the band reinventing itself as a powerful jam band. Tour de Fromage was followed by the similarly minded Hallucino Genetics tour, including a first ever complete rendition of the Frizzle Fry album, commemorated on their first live DVD. In 2006, the band released Blame It On the Fish, a DVD documentary of the Tour de Fromage, and a greatest hits compilation CD entitled They Can’t All Be Zingers.
Instrumentation
Les Claypool: see Claypool's Unusual Instruments section.
Larry Lalonde:
- Acoustic guitar: Over the Falls, Closing Time (Internet Infiltration)
- Electric Banjo: Air Is Getting Slippery, De Anza Jig, Drum/Whamola Jam (11/23/03); as well as all songs from 01/09/96 all banjo show - Bastards, Groundhog, Hello Skinny, John, Tweekers, To Defy the Laws Of Tradition, Tommy, Wynona
Tim (Herb) Alexander:
- Jazz drumset: played on Bob Cock And Yellow Sock shows.
- Marimba: Rapscallion
Live Repertoire
Suck on This
- The Heckler – Premiered 1989, played regularly in 1990, it essentially disappeared by 1992, then was revived during the spring 1996 tour. The Brain lineup played it a number of times in fall 1997-98, then it was dropped again until its two time revival in the closing days of the Tour de Fromage. Essentially identical to the Suck On This and Antipop versions. Has been released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com
- Jellikit – Premiered 1987, played sporadically through 1996, it reappeared briefly during the fall 2003 tour, then made only one appearance during the summer 2004 tour. Performed essentially as the Suck On This version, although the mid-section typically does not contain a drum solo, but rather a bridge back to the chorus or a segue to another song. Alternate version: Bastardizing Jellikit (has never been played live). Has been released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com
Note: Album was recorded live 02/25/89 and 03/05/89. All other songs on this live album exist in studio versions elsewhere and will thus be dealt with later. The Heckler description was left here since the studio version released on Antipop was an unlabelled entry.
Frizzle Fry
- To Defy The Laws Of Tradition – Premiered 1987, played regularly through 2006, including nightly renditions on the Hallucino Genetics tour. Essentially identical to the studio version until 10/29/05, when it first featured some jamming. Official live versions: Videoplasty (10/14/98), Animals DVD (05/03/89).
Groundhog's Day – Premiered 1988, played regularly through 2006, including nightly renditions on the Hallucino Genetics tour. Essentially identical to the studio version through 1996; starting in 1997 it became a jam vehicle. On the fall 1999 tour, Les would jokingly prompt Ler to solo like other famous guitarists (e.g. Santana, Van Halen, Ted Nugent). Alternate version: Bob Cock and Yellow Sock. Official live versions: Suck On This, Animals DVD (??/88 with Huth and Lane, also 12/31/93).
- Too Many Puppies – One of the first songs Les ever wrote, premiered in 1987, played regularly through 2006, including nightly renditions on the Hallucino Genetics tour. Essentially identical to the studio version; the mid-section has frequently been used as a spot for cover songs (typically Master of Puppets, Crazy Train, and Hello Skinny). Alternate versions: a toned down, one time performance on 12/31/94 with Les on electric upright; and the mellower Rhinoplasty arrangement premiered 2/10/98. Official live versions: Videoplasty (10/14/98), Animals DVD (05/03/89).
- Mr. Know It All – Premiered 1989, played regularly through 1996, it made only three appearances during the Brain era. It was then revived in 2003, including nightly renditions on the Hallucino Genetics tour. Essentially identical to the studio version. Official live versions on: MOM soundtrack album and Blame It On the Fish DVD; a 1995 version was also temporarily available off primussucks.com as an itunes bonus track for purchasers of the Zingers greatest hits CD.
- Frizzle Fry – Premiered 1988, played regularly in 1989-91, it petered out in 1992-3 and disappeared entirely in 1994-5, until it was briefly revived in the waning days before Tim’s departure in spring 1996. During the Brain era, Primus began playing it regularly again on the fall 1997 and spring 1998 tours, shelved it from summer 1998 through 1999, then reinstated it in 2000. It was again revived in 2003, including nightly renditions on the Hallucino Genetics tour. Essentially played like the studio version, until 10/29/05, when it first featured some jamming. Official live versions on: Suck On This (02/25/89), Live from Bonnaroo 2004 CD (06/12/04), Animals DVD (05/03/89).
- John the Fisherman – Premiered 1987, and regularly played through 2006, including nightly renditions on the Hallucino Genetics tour. Essentially performed as the studio version, except for the intro, which at times included the Poetry and Prose outro bass line. Alternate version: Bob Cock and Yellow Sock. Official live versions on: Suck On This, Cheesy Home video (brief excerpt of 05/25/92 BC&YS version).
- You Can’t Kill Michael Malloy – Never actually played live, but broadcast in extended format through the PA nightly on the Hallucino Genetics tour as a mid-set break.
- Toys Go Winding Down – Premiered 1989, played regularly through 1996, then brought back in 2003, including nightly renditions on the Hallucino Genetics tour. The live version has always included a band intro not on the studio release. 1989-90 versions were otherwise identical to the studio version; subsequently from 1991-6 the song always segued into Pudding Time before the bass solo section (after the line “and the stripers start to fade away, it’s pudding time”). In 2003 it was revived in full glory and became a jam vehicle. Also in 2003 the Toys > Pudding medley was occasionally invoked.
- Pudding Time – Premiered 1987, and regularly played through 2006, including nightly renditions on the Hallucino Genetics tour. Essentially performed as the studio version. From 1991-6, often part of a medley comprising Toys > Pudding > Thieves > Pudding. Official live versions: Suck On This, Animals DVD (08/12/95 bootleg quality).
- Sathington Willoughby - Premiered 05/29/04 and played nightly on the Hallucino Genetics tour only. The live version was more fully developed than the skeletal studio ditty, with Les on upright and Ler on slide guitar.
- Spegetti Western – Premiered 1989 and played through 1996, then revived in 2003, including nightly renditions on the Hallucino Genetics tour. Essentially performed as the studio version; the Hallucino Genetics tour version segued out of the Drum/Whamola Jam. Alternate version: 12/31/94 - Instrumental vamp with Angelo Moore guesting.
- Harold Of The Rocks - Premiered 1989, played regularly through 1996; during the Brain era played summer 1997, shelved for the fall 1997 tour, then brought back a handful of times in 1998, until it returned to terrorize setlists near nightly in 1999-2000. It was again revived in 2003, including nightly renditions on the Hallucino Genetics tour. Unique amongst the Frizzle Fry material in that it has always been a major jam vehicle, with excellent Ler solos. Official live version on Suck On This, Animals DVD (brief snippet w/ Hammett and Cantrell).
- To Defy - Premiered 05/29/04 and played nightly on the Hallucino Genetics tour only. The live version was more fully developed than the skeletal studio ditty, with Les triggering loops and Tim playing a very tribal beat as Primus left the stage one by one.
Note: Besides the 5 songs released on Suck On This, all original material off the album has also been released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com (all but Sathington Willoughby and To Defy were played on the Tour de Fromage, and the entire album was played at all summer 2004 shows), as well as on the Hallucino Genetics DVD documenting the 06/26/04 show.
The original demos of this album included the Hello Skinny/Constantinople medley, which was not included on the 1990 CD pressing. The 2002 re-release of Frizzle Fry included these two covers - see Covers section.
Sailing the Seas of Cheese
- Seas of Cheese - Premiered 03/16/91, played regularly from 1992-98, then reinstated in 2003, with nightly renditions on the Tour de Fromage. After only two appearances during Hallucino Genetics, Cheese was heavily played in 2006. Essentially performed as the studio version (i.e. Les alone on bass and vocals) until 2003, when the song gained a full band composed second section. Official live versions: on Mrs Blaileen single B side (summer 1993), Videoplasty (1014/98).
- Here Come the Bastards - Premiered possibly in 1989, definitely by 1990, consistently played from 1991-2006, including nightly renditions on the Tour de Fromage. Usually includes some theme and variation jamming, has at times involved audience participation, with a sing a long chant of the lyrics "here they come, here they come." Official live versions: Cheesy Home video (2 excerpts), Videoplasty (10/14/98).
- Sgt. Baker – Premiered 1987, performed intermittently through 1992, then disappeared until 1999, when it resurfaced in its full glory during the Antipop tour. It was played heavily from 1999-2006, including nightly renditions on the Tour de Fromage. Essentially performed as the studio version. Official live versions: Animals (rare mid 80s version with Huth and early drummer Wright) and Hallucino Genetics DVDs (06/26/04).
- American Life - Premiered 02/08/91, played sporadically from 1991-6, then heavily from 2003-6, including nightly renditions on the Tour de Fromage. Essentially like the studio version during Tim’s first stint, in 2003 this became the major jam number of the Seas of Cheese cover set during Tour de Fromage. Official live versions on: Hallucino Genetics (06/26/04), Blame It On the Fish DVDs.
- Jerry Was A Racecar Driver - Premiered on 01/12/90, this has been a live staple ever since, including nightly renditions on the Tour de Fromage. MTV video included live footage (date unknown). Essentially performed as the studio version; the only alternate version was the Bob Cock and Yellow Sock rendition. Official live versions on: They Can’t All Be Zingers (Best Buy bonus disc: 08/13/94), Hallucino Genetics (06/26/04), Blame It On the Fish DVDs; official video included overdubbed live footage from a 1990 Petaluma show.
- Eleven – Premiered 1987, then reworked by late 1990 into the Seas Of Cheese version and sporadically played through 1996, Brain tackled it a handful of times in 1997, then after just one appearance is winter ’98, it disappeared until its return 2003-6, including nightly renditions on the Tour de Fromage. Has typically included some mid-song band improvisation and extended Tim drum intros; on the Tour de Fromage the song segued out of the massive Drum/Whamola Jams. Official live versions: Cheesy Home video and Animals DVD have different brief excerpts of Tim’s drum intro.
- Is It Luck? – Premiered 1987 and sporadically played through 1993, it reappeared in 2003-6, including nightly renditions on the Tour de Fromage. Essentially performed as the studio version, the mid section often included various covers.
- Grandad's Little Ditty - This Les a capella poem was premiered 02/14/91, played occasionally ‘91-2, then resurfaced 2003-4 when it was played nightly on the Tour de Fromage only.
- Tommy The Cat – Premiered 07/13/87, played heavily 1989-92, mostly given a break in 1993-4, then played semi-regularly in 1995-6. During Brain’s era, it was played nearly nightly in 1997-8, then minimally in 1999-2000. It was again played nightly on the Tour de Fromage, but only 3 times on Hallucino Genetics and once on the fall 2006 tour. The 1997 Tommy was the most regimented, always containing The Awakening, followed by a Brain drum solo, and then a short bass and drums jam (the Rhinoplasty version from 12/31/97 provides a good example). Versions from most other eras contained at least a ripping bass solo; Tommy has often featured various teases (famously Master of Puppets in the early 90s), segues, drum intros (Tim used the studio version’s opening snare break live in 1990-1 and on the Tour de Fromage, Brain had his own intro - listen to the Rhinoplasty version), guest performers and massive jams (all spring 1998 versions included DJ Disk as a nightly guest dueling turntables with Brain and Les). Official live versions: Suck On This, Rhinoplasty (12/31/97), Videoplasty (10/14/98), Cheesy Home Video (two jam excerpts w/ DJ Scribble), Animals DVD (05/25/92 alternate BC&YS version; brief snippets of several standard renditions).
- Sathington Waltz – Premiered 1991 yet rarely played, it resurfaced in 2003-4 when it was played nightly on the Tour de Fromage only. The 1991 renditions similar to the studio version; for Tour de Fromage Primus spiffed it up with extended jams and nightly appearances on handheld keyboards by Bob Cock.
- Those Damned Blue Collar Tweekers - Premiered 01/12/90, played regularly from late 1990-2006, including nightly renditions on the Tour de Fromage. The middle section has usually featured a short bass or full band jam, although this was replaced from fall 1997 through spring 1998 by an excerpt of Highball With the Devil, and from late 1998 through 1999 by the Ballad of Buckethead, with the masked one sitting in and stealing the solo spot. Official live versions on: Woodstock 1994 compilation, They Can’t All Be Zingers (Best Buy bonus disc) and Animals DVD (all feature the same 08/13/94 performance), Videoplasty (10/14/98).
- Fish On - Premiered 12/29/90 (intro and verses only), first complete rendition 02/14/91, then played regularly through 1993, it reappeared in 2003-4 for nightly renditions on the Tour de Fromage, then was performed only three times on Hallucino Genetics before disappearing again into the deep. 1991-3 versions ended after the group instrumental section, whereas the Fromage version included the "fish on" outro choruses from the studio rendition.
- Los Bastardos – Premiered 10/13/2003 and played nightly on the 2003-4 Tour de Fromage only, the live version was a monstrously jammed out rave up of the chaotic overdubbed studio track, augmented by extra players (likely Bob Cock and several crew members; in fact Les usually played an extra rack of roto toms, while someone else played bass).
NOTE: All of the material off the album has been released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com (full sets on all Tour de Fromage shows from 10/14/03-03/13/04, plus select songs featured on shows from 5/29-6/26/04).
Pork Soda
- My Name Is Mud - Premiered 05/03/92. Played routinely from 1992-2006. Essentially like the studio version; the only exception being that during the Brain era the drums and bass coda was lengthened. Like mud itself, it sticks to everything and just will not go away. Alternate version: 04/19/96 with chorus lyrics changed to “We are the Cows” (in commemoration of then opening act). Official live versions: Mrs Blaileen single B side (summer 1993), They Can’t All Be Zingers (Best Buy bonus disc) and Animals DVD (both 08/13/94 performance), Family Values compilation CD (10/99), Horrible Swill video (03/03/98), Animals (brief snippet from 1997-8) and Hallucino Genetics DVDs (06/26/04); also released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com
- Welcome To This World – Premiered 06/18/93 in the only known performance to exist. Essentially identical to the studio version.
- Bob – Premiered 05/03/92, played regularly 1992-6; Brain played it just twice (1998 FreakOut). After Primus brought it back for the Tour de Fromage, it was played just 3 times on Hallucino Genetics and twice in fall 2006. Essentially played as the studio version through 1996; the two Brain versions and all versions from 2003 on featured some jamming. Official live versions: They Can’t All Be Zingers (Best Buy bonus disc: 08/13/94), Blame It On the Fish DVD; also released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com
- DMV- Premiered 05/03/92, played regularly fall 1993, then 3 times only in fall 2003. Essentially played as the studio version in 1993; 2003 versions had minor jamming. MTV video included both canned empty stage footage and clips from the 10/01/93 video shoot. Released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com
- Ol' Diamondback Sturgeon - Premiered 06/19/93, played occasionally in 1993-4, then again sporadically in 2003-4. 1993-4 versions stuck to the studio rendition; from 2003 on this was a major jam vehicle. Released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com
- Nature Boy - Premiered 05/03/92, played regularly 1992-6 and fall 1997-1998, then 2003-6. The very earliest 1992 versions were played at a much slower tempo, otherwise all 1993-8 versions were similar to the studio one. Beginning 2003, the song became a major jam vehicle. Nature Boy also distinguished itself by providing a steady home to Hello Skinny during 1993-6. Official live version on Blame It On the Fish DVD; also released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com
- Pork Soda - Premiered 05/03/92, played regularly 1993-5, occasionally 1996, then 4 times fall 2003 and once each winter and summer 2004 respectively. Essentially played like the album version. Released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com
- The Pressman – Premiered 02/25/89, played 1989-90, then once in 1992 and twice in 1996, it reappeared in 2003 and made 5 appearances each on Tour de Fromage and Hallucino Genetics. Essentially performed like the album version through 1996; in 2003 it became a major jam vehicle. Live version released on Suck On This and Hallucino Genetics DVD (06/26/04); also released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com
- Mr. Krinkle - Premiered 05/03/92, played regularly 1993 and rarely 1994, Primus brought it back with a vengeance in 2003-6. Essentially performed like the album version. Official live versions: Blame It On the Fish and Animals DVDs (12/31/93); also released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com
- Air Is Getting Slippery - Premiered 08/06/93, played in 1993-4; Brain tackled it twice only (1998 Freakout); it then made two appearances on Tour de Fromage. Live versions featured banjy shredding by Ler. Released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com
- Hamburger Train - Premiered 05/03/92, played regularly 1993, rarely 1995-6, then just once in 2003 and 2006 apiece. Probably similar to studio version and played in excerpted form. Released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com
NOTE: Wounded Knee is not live material. Hail Santa has never been played live. Pork Chop's Little Ditty remains unconfirmed - there are reports that it was played in 1993.
Tales from the Punchbowl
- Professor Nutbutter's House Of Treats - Premiered as instrumental excerpt 12/31/94, complete performance premiered 06/03/95. Played regularly 1995-6, then returned fall 2003, played twice more in winter 2004. Essentially like the studio version. Released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com
Mrs. Blaileen - Premiered on 06/03/95, played regularly 1995-6, returned to setlists fall 2003, then played twice winter 2004 and only once on Hallucino Genetics. Usually featured some improv. Released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com
- Wynona's Big Brown Beaver - Premiered on 12/31/94 with different lyrics (the first 'official' version was probably on 06/03/95), played regularly 1995-6, then during Brain era there were sporadic performances in summer-fall 1997, and again in fall 1999-2000. The song then went on extended hiatus again, only to be prominently featured on the greatest hits fall 2006 tour. Essentially like the studio version.
- Southbound Pachyderm - Premiered 07/19/95, played regularly 1995-6 and 1997-8, then made only one appearance in 1999. It returned on the fall 2003 tour and was routinely played 2003-6. While 1995-6 versions had minimal jamming, beginning 1997 Pachyderms became a major jam vehicle. Summer 2004 shows witnessed several sweet segues out of Pachyderm into Rush’s La Villa Strangiato. Official live versions: Animals (08/12/95 – bootleg quality), Hallucino Genetics (06/26/04), Blame It On the Fish DVDs; also released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com
- Year Of The Parrot - Premiered on 12/31/94, played rarely in 1995. Essentially like the studio version.
- Hellbound 17 ½ - Premiered 11/11/95, played rarely fall 1995, it reappeared once on the fall 2003 leg of Tour de Fromage. Essentially like the studio version. Released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com
- Glass Sandwich - Premiered 11/14/95, played rarely fall 1995, it made 3 appearances fall 2003, then one each winter and summer 2004 respectively. The 1995 versions were similar to the studio version, 2003-4 renditions usually had some improv. Released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com
- Del Davis Tree Farm - Premiered 09/23/95, played rarely fall 1995, and then it bought the farm, at least until 3 appearances in fall 2003, then one more in summer 2004. Essentially like the studio version. Released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com
- De Anza Jig - Premiered 07/19/95, played 1995-6 regularly, Brain touched it only once (at his first show on 12/31/96), then reappeared in 2003. Primus played it just five times total between Tour de Fromage and Hallucino Genetics, then unleashed it on the fall 2006 tour. Usually jammed out with Ler banjo solos. Official live version on Blame It On the Fish DVD; also released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com
- On The Tweek Again - Premiered as excerpt on 12/31/94, first complete performance 10/17/95, played rarely fall 1995. Essentially like the album version.
- Over The Electric Grapevine - Premiered 07/19/95 and played regularly during 1995-6, then reappeared as a regular in 2003-6. 1995-6 versions stayed true to the album; in 2003 the song regularly featured improv, with some versions reaching monster status (e.g. 10/29/05 – that performance was temporarily available off primussucks.com as a video download). Official live version on Blame It On the Fish DVD; also released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com
NOTE: Space Farm and Captain Shiner have never been played live.
Brown Album
- Fisticuffs - Premiered 10/19/97, rarely played fall 1997 and winter 1998. Essentially like the studio version.
- Golden Boy - Premiered on 12/31/96, played sporadically summer 1997 through winter 1998. Essentially played like the album version.
- Over The Falls - Premiered 06/22/97, played heavily summer and fall 1997, then rarely in winter and summer 1998. Essentially like the studio version.
- Shake Hands With Beef - Premiered on 04/12/97. Played heavily summer 1997, it made only a handful of appearances in fall 1997 and winter 1998, and barring one very short jam at a 2000 show, it was not heard from again until Primus resurrected it 3 times on the greatest hits fall 2006 tour (making Beef the first Brain-era Primus song that Tim has played live since the 2003 reunion). Essentially like the studio version.
- Camelback Cinema – Premiered 02/14/98, only known performance to date.
- Puddin' Taine - Premiered 04/12/97, heavily played summer 1997 through summer 1998, then only a handful of times at special shows (Videoplasty, FreakOut 98 and several off-Ozzfest summer 1999 dates) until being retired in 09/99. Essentially like the studio version, with a slower drums and bass intro based on the verse riff. Official live version released on Horrible Swill video (03/03/98).
- Bob's Party Time Lounge - Premiered 09/25/97 and played regularly fall 1997 through summer 1998. The only song off the Brown album with significant improvisation, live renditions began with an ambient, King Crimson-ish bass and guitar intro, and always included lengthy Ler solos. Official live versions released on Horrible Swill (03/03/98), Videoplasty (10/14/98) and Animals (brief snippet of Ler intro from 1997-8 show) DVDs and Rhinoplasty CD (12/31/97).
- Duchess and the Proverbial Mind Spread - Premiered 06/08/97, played regularly 1997-8, rarely in 1999 (3 off-Ozzfest shows, then 4 times on Antipop Leg 1) and 2000. Played like the album version, with room for improvised drum breaks by Brain over an extended bass and guitar vamp before the composed guitar solo. Official live version on Animals DVD (05/11/98).
- Coddingtown - Premiered on 12/31/96, played sporadically summer and fall 1997, then just 3 times in winter 1998. Essentially like the album version.
- Kalamazoo - Premiered 09/25/97, played regularly fall 1997-8, then just 3 times in fall 1999 and 4 times in 2000. Esentially like the album version. Official live version on Videoplasty (10/14/98).
The Chastising of Renegade - Premiered 05/26/98 and played that year only. Played heavily on the Europlasty tour that summer and only once or twice in the states at the end of the year. Essentially like the album version.
NOTE: Return Of Sathington Willoughby, Hats Off and Arnie were never performed live. Restin Bones’ was never played as an actual song; Brain incorporated the drum groove into his summer 1997 Tommy drum solos.
Antipop
- Electric Uncle Sam - Premiered 10/17/99 and played regularly through 2/00. Essentially similar to the studio version, except for a short intro vamp played at some 2000 shows. The 2000 shows were also missing the second rhythm guitar line (Buckethead, the guest-in-residence all of fall 1999, would play Tom Morello's studio part. Despite Buckethead's nightly appearance, this song never generated any jamming).
- Laquer Head - Premiered 10/99 and played regularly through 2000. Essentially like the studio version, with an extended bass intro that included the fast ostinato from between the first and second verses. MTV video used footage from 02/26/00 video shoot. Official live versions: Family Values compilation CD and Animals DVD (both versions from 10/99 tour).
- Antipop - Premiered 05/29/99 and played regularly through 2000. Essentially like the studio version during 1999, 2000 versions occasionally included short jams.
Greet The Sacred Cow - Premiered 11/17/99 and played through 2000. Essentially like the album version.
- Final Voyage Of The Liquid Sky - Premiered 11/06/99 and played through 2000. Essentially like the studio version.
NOTE: The Intro is not a separate track (it's an excerpt of Waits' Mellotron line from Coattails). Natural Joe, Mama Didn't Raise No Fool, Dirty Drowning Man, Ballad Of Bodacious, Power Mad and Coattails Of A Dead Man have never been played live. Eclectic Electric was teased several times, but never formally played. Heckler live info listed under Suck On This page.
Animals Should Not Try To Act Like People
- Carpenter and the Dainty Bride – Premiered 10/13/03 and played regularly through 2004. A major jam vehicle. Released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com
- Pilcher’s Squad – Premiered 10/13/03 and played heavily fall 2003, then just once in spring 2004. Essentially like the studio version. Official live version on Blame It On the Fish DVD; also released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com
- Mary the Ice Cube – Premiered 10/18/03 and played sporadically through 2004, then just once on fall 2006 tour (presumably unrehearsed, as it appeared in a skeletal instrumental version). Usually featured some improv. Official live version on Blame It On the Fish DVD; also released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com
- Last Superpower aka Rapscallion – Premiered 10/15/03, played through 2004. The loop based mid section (right after Tim’s marimba part) was extended to 5-6 minutes live, disrupting the flow of the song and bringing the mosh pit to a standstill. Official live version on Hallucino Genetics DVD (06/26/04); also released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com
- My Friend Fats – Premiered 10/14/03 and played heavily through 2004. A major jam vehicle. Official live versions on Live from Bonnaroo 2004 (06/12/04) and Hallucino Genetics (06/26/04) DVDs; also released in official bootleg download form on primuslive.com
They Can’t All Be Zingers: the Best of Primus
NOTE: Although this 2006 greatest hits CD contained 16 previously released studio tracks (excepting a longer rendition of Beef), the Best Buy version included a bonus live CD from the 08/13/94 Woodstock performance: Bob, Jerry, Mud, Tweekers/Star Spangled Banner